Mamma Mia
// May 31st, 2011 // No Comments » // Blog, Restaurant Reviews
I usually know better than to try out Italian Restaurants when I am out of town. Oh, sure I have been to some really spectacular places, but I have been to even more that were nothing short of horrendous. The problem is that I am a bit of a snob when it comes to Italian food. First, I grew up in Youngstown, Ohio. Nobody makes better meatballs than my mother, period, end of discussion. In Northeast Ohio there were tons of little corner mom and pop places that served authentic and nothing short of amazing Italian food. Then I traveled to Italy several times. So I am really hard to please. I admit it.
So I am not sure what possessed me to stop in Mamma Mia’s Italian Restaurant in Heath, Ohio. The parking lot was empty and I was the only patron. The red flags were going up everywhere. Yet I sat down. I quickly looked over the menu and ordered the sliced Italian sausage as an appetizer, a side salad and egg plant parmigiana. Much to my chagrin, they were out of the eggplant parm. My second choice was the manicotti. To be complete, I ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza to go.
While I waited for my order, I chatted with the owner. He told me how business has been pretty slow. He shared that he had been open for about four months. He then excused himself and went to bring my sausage. I wasn’t getting my hopes up, but it did look interesting, thin slices of sausage in a spicy marinara sauce. It was a pretty large serving, and I was already anticipating having a few bites and then focusing on my pasta dish to come. The owner told me he made everything from scratch- really, in Heath, Ohio. So I started to eat it as he told me how he learned to cook from his mom and trained and worked in other Italian restaurants. It was amazing, the sausage was tender and flavorful, and the sauce was truly spectacular. Fortunately, the place was empty and no one saw me licking up the sauce. The manicotti was very good. Manicotti a simple dish’s that’s relatively easy to make and usually taste pretty good. The only big mistake is to over season it- this one was perfect. Being the snob that I am, no gold stars for manicotti, I was waiting for the tiramisu. I always order tiramisu; it’s my barometer of a good Italian restaurant! This one was home made and was over the top! The pizza was incredible as well.
So I am sold- I found my new favorite place to eat while in the Newark area. I can’t wait for lunch tomorrow. If you live in the area or are passing by, stop in and support this place. Restaurants like this need to survive! It’s a special place were fresh ingredients are used by someone who obviously has a passion for what they are doing and does it well. With a little luck, I can get a glass of wine next time I am there! Good food, fair prices and really nice people working there. Check it out: Mamma Mia’s, 773 Hebron Road, Heath, Ohio, (740) 522-0000. They are open Tuesday through Sunday from 11:00am to 9:00pm. See you there.
TC Chuck










